Greatest soccer players

We asked 12 models: The greatest soccer (association football) players of all time. Each named its own top 10.

Agreement between models
84%
Same model, run twice
92%
Different picks
12

When agreement between models is well below a model's agreement with itself, the split reflects real differences in taste rather than randomness.

The consensus

Each cell is the position that model gave the pick; blank means it left the pick off. Click a row for each model's reasoning.

#PickScoreListed byClaude Opus 5.5GPT-6.1 SolGemini 4 ArgonQwen 3.8 MaxDeepSeek V4 ProGLM-5.3Grok 4.7Muse WonderKimi K3MiniMax M3Mistral Large 4Nemotron 3 Ultra

Most divisive

Picks most models listed, at very different positions

Hot takes

Picks that appear on only one ballot

No pick appeared on just one ballot.

Every ballot

Hover a pick to find it on the other ballots. Marked picks appear on no other ballot.

Claude Opus 5.5

  1. Lionel Messi
  2. Pelé
  3. Diego Maradona
  4. Cristiano Ronaldo
  5. Johan Cruyff
  6. Alfredo Di Stéfano
  7. Franz Beckenbauer
  8. Zinedine Zidane
  9. Ronaldo Nazário
  10. Ferenc Puskás

98% with consensus · 99% self-consistent

GPT-6.1 Sol

  1. Lionel Messi
  2. Pelé
  3. Diego Maradona
  4. Cristiano Ronaldo
  5. Johan Cruyff
  6. Alfredo Di Stéfano
  7. Franz Beckenbauer
  8. Zinedine Zidane
  9. Ronaldo Nazário
  10. Ferenc Puskás

98% with consensus · 99% self-consistent

Gemini 4 Argon

  1. Lionel Messi
  2. Pelé
  3. Diego Maradona
  4. Cristiano Ronaldo
  5. Johan Cruyff
  6. Alfredo Di Stéfano
  7. Franz Beckenbauer
  8. Zinedine Zidane
  9. Ronaldo Nazário
  10. Ferenc Puskás

98% with consensus · 100% self-consistent

Qwen 3.8 Max

  1. Lionel Messi
  2. Pelé
  3. Diego Maradona
  4. Cristiano Ronaldo
  5. Johan Cruyff
  6. Alfredo Di Stéfano
  7. Franz Beckenbauer
  8. Zinedine Zidane
  9. Ronaldo Nazário
  10. Ronaldinho

98% with consensus · 91% self-consistent

DeepSeek V4 Pro

  1. Lionel Messi
  2. Diego Maradona
  3. Pelé
  4. Johan Cruyff
  5. Cristiano Ronaldo
  6. Zinedine Zidane
  7. Franz Beckenbauer
  8. Alfredo Di Stéfano
  9. Ronaldo Nazário
  10. Michel Platini

88% with consensus · 93% self-consistent

GLM-5.3

  1. Pelé
  2. Lionel Messi
  3. Diego Maradona
  4. Johan Cruyff
  5. Cristiano Ronaldo
  6. Franz Beckenbauer
  7. Zinedine Zidane
  8. Alfredo Di Stéfano
  9. Ronaldo Nazário
  10. Michel Platini

81% with consensus · 81% self-consistent

Grok 4.7

  1. Lionel Messi
  2. Diego Maradona
  3. Pelé
  4. Cristiano Ronaldo
  5. Johan Cruyff
  6. Alfredo Di Stéfano
  7. Zinedine Zidane
  8. Franz Beckenbauer
  9. Ronaldo Nazário
  10. Ferenc Puskás

90% with consensus · 97% self-consistent

Muse Wonder

  1. Lionel Messi
  2. Pelé
  3. Diego Maradona
  4. Cristiano Ronaldo
  5. Johan Cruyff
  6. Franz Beckenbauer
  7. Ronaldo Nazário
  8. Alfredo Di Stéfano
  9. Zinedine Zidane
  10. Michel Platini

98% with consensus · 98% self-consistent

Kimi K3

  1. Lionel Messi
  2. Pelé
  3. Diego Maradona
  4. Cristiano Ronaldo
  5. Johan Cruyff
  6. Franz Beckenbauer
  7. Zinedine Zidane
  8. Ronaldo Nazário
  9. Michel Platini
  10. Alfredo Di Stéfano

97% with consensus · 100% self-consistent

MiniMax M3

  1. Diego Maradona
  2. Pelé
  3. Johan Cruyff
  4. Lionel Messi
  5. Franz Beckenbauer
  6. Ronaldo Nazário
  7. Cristiano Ronaldo
  8. Zinedine Zidane
  9. Ronaldinho
  10. Michel Platini

64% with consensus · 82% self-consistent

Mistral Large 4

  1. Lionel Messi
  2. Pelé
  3. Diego Maradona
  4. Cristiano Ronaldo
  5. Johan Cruyff
  6. Franz Beckenbauer
  7. Alfredo Di Stéfano
  8. Zinedine Zidane
  9. Ronaldo Nazário
  10. Michel Platini

100% with consensus · 84% self-consistent

Nemotron 3 Ultra

  1. Pelé
  2. Diego Maradona
  3. Lionel Messi
  4. Johan Cruyff
  5. Cristiano Ronaldo
  6. Zinedine Zidane
  7. Franz Beckenbauer
  8. Alfredo Di Stéfano
  9. Ronaldo Nazário
  10. Michel Platini

72% with consensus · 79% self-consistent

Who agrees with whom

Overlap between two models' lists, weighted toward the top · 100 means identical · Color runs from 61 (lightest) to 100 (darkest)

Claude Opus 5.5GPT-6.1 SolGemini 4 ArgonQwen 3.8 MaxDeepSeek V4 ProGLM-5.3Grok 4.7Muse WonderKimi K3MiniMax M3Mistral Large 4Nemotron 3 Ultra
Claude Opus 5.5100100998779929695629872
GPT-6.1 Sol100100998779929695629872
Gemini 4 Argon100100998779929695629872
Qwen 3.8 Max9999998779919695629872
DeepSeek V4 Pro8787878776948787658878
GLM-5.37979797976728080678192
Grok 4.79292929194728888619072
Muse Wonder9696969687808897659871
Kimi K39595959587808897659772
MiniMax M36262626265676165656472
Mistral Large 49898989888819098976472
Nemotron 3 Ultra7272727278927271727272